Shane Gillis Addresses 'SNL' Monologue Backlash, Calls Performance 'Solid C Minus'
Shane Gillis said on The Joe Rogan Experience that his Saturday Night Live monologue deserved a "solid C minus" and blamed the backlash, which included criticism of a women's gym clothing joke, on the current climate.
Newsnibs Staff
- 2026-11-15
- Updated 7:15 PM UTC
(New York, United States)
Shane Gillis, the 38-year-old comedian, said on Friday that his October 10 "Saturday Night Live" monologue deserved a "solid C minus" and that the backlash to it came from the current "climate." He spoke on "The Joe Rogan Experience" alongside Rogan and fellow comedians Mark Normand and Ari Shaffir.
The seven-minute monologue included a joke about women's gym clothing. "I haven't been to the gym in so long, I didn't know women just dress like whores now?" Gillis said. He called the clothing "artificial bait-coloured" and said he was "in the background of like 10 TikToks right now." The joke also took aim at neon shorts and the way fabric wrinkles. Viewers and public figures criticized it as misogynistic and as objectifying women.
On the podcast, Gillis said he told SNL producers beforehand that the material was weak and that "there's no controversy." He said the show does not approve a professional comedian's monologue. "They don't approve it... you don't write your set and give it to them," he said, adding that the show could shut a bit down if it wanted to. He said the SNL team did not stop him, and that he had promised them the set would mainly be self-deprecating. He described it as "calling myself fat for f-king 10 minutes." No statement from SNL or NBC on the approval question was part of the coverage.
Gillis tied the reaction to a national reckoning with sexual violence, citing the Cornell 7 case. He said he has no problem with women wearing skin-tight clothing and called it "wonderful," and he pushed back on Rogan's suggestion that the issue was specific to gender. Asked about touring comedians said to be criticizing him behind his back, he said the negative comments came mainly from "struggling middling comedians." Rogan called the public reaction "overblown" and said "this is a weird time where everyone's just looking to get upset."
Gillis said he deleted his social media this time. "The first time I got fired, I kept social media. This time, I just deleted everything immediately," he said.
Among the critics, actor Dan Levy, a former SNL host, said in an Instagram reel that he was "speechless that something like that can exist on live national television." He said: "Women wearing short shorts to the gym does not make them whores. It makes the men calling them whores, misogynists." Levy also said complacency creates environments for sexual assault and that women "are superior human beings to men." Former SNL cast member Ego Nwodim posted a gym selfie captioned "whore reporting for duty." Kathy Griffin was also among the critics. Author Jessica Valenti condemned the remarks on Instagram as dehumanizing. SNL alum Dana Carvey defended Gillis and treated the line as a standard joke.
SNL hired Gillis in 2019 and removed him days later, after recordings surfaced in which he used racist and homophobic slurs, including an anti-Asian slur on a podcast. Gillis has maintained the remarks were taken out of context. He returned to host in February 2024 and has hosted three times since. A Gillis comedy special at Lincoln Financial Field in July set Guinness World Records for attendance and ticket sales.
Photo by M G on Unsplash